Where Conscience Is Free: Brooklyn's Central Congregational Church
'Abdu'l-Bahá, The Promulgation of Universal Peace, (1922), Bahá'í Publishing Trust · Read original
When in Bahá'í history
Brooklyn (today: Brooklyn, NY, USA)
On the evening of June 16, 1912, ‘Abdu’l-Bahá took the pulpit of the Central Congregational Church on Hancock Street in Brooklyn. The congregation was Protestant, well educated, deeply rooted in the tradition of dissent and free conscience that had founded New England Congregationalism. Esther Foster took the notes that survive.
The Master began where He had begun in many of His American talks: with the diagnosis of religious discord. He did not blame doctrine, He blamed inheritance. The trouble, He said, is not that people believe different things; the trouble is that most people have not believed. They have inherited an opinion from their fathers, and they have called it faith.
The remedy is the independent investigation of truth. And for that investigation a particular kind of public life is required:
When freedom of conscience, liberty of thought and right of speech prevail — that is to say, when every man according to his own idealization may give expression to his beliefs — development and growth are inevitable.
Free expression is, in this telling, not a political add-on to religion. It is the condition without which religion cannot do its work. A truth that is not freely sought is not yet believed.
He then placed His central claim about the religions:
The divine religion is reality, and reality is not multiple; it is one. Therefore, the foundations of the religious systems are one because all proceed from the indivisible reality.
The diversity of religions is real but secondary. What is primary is the single reality from which all the Founders draw. The Manifestations differ in language, in time, in custom; They do not differ in essence. The essential purpose of the religion of God, He said,
is to establish unity amongst mankind.
Where it does not establish unity, it has missed its purpose. Where it has been used to justify enmity, it has been used backwards. He left the Brooklyn congregation with a single test of every faith they had been taught:
If the Holy Books were rightly understood, none of this discord and distress would have existed, but love and fellowship would have prevailed instead.
The talk reframed the work of the religious thinker. The Congregational tradition prized the reading of scripture; the Master invited it to read scripture with one eye on whether the result was love.
Source: 'Abdu'l-Bahá, The Promulgation of Universal Peace, talk of June 16, 1912 at the Central Congregational Church, Brooklyn. Notes by Esther Foster. Public domain text from the Bahá'í Reference Library.
Cite this story
'Abdu'l-Bahá. (1922). *The Promulgation of Universal Peace*. Bahá'í Publishing Trust. https://www.bahai.org/library/authoritative-texts/abdul-baha/promulgation-universal-peace/
Record yourself reading this story
Recording stays on this device only. Nothing is uploaded.
Related stories
True Shepherds Gather, They Do Not Scatter: Fanwood, 1912
At the Town Hall in Fanwood, New Jersey on May 31, 1912, 'Abdu'l-Bahá named the chaos of the modern world as a chaos produced by religion itself — by the partisanship of sects clinging to inheritance rather than searching for truth. The true Manifestations, He said, are shepherds; their work is to gather, never to scatter.
A Question for Two Thousand Friends
Standing before a huge crowd in a great synagogue, 'Abdu'l-Bahá asked one gentle, brave question that no one there had expected to hear.
Why Not Praise Christ and Muḥammad: 'Abdu'l-Bahá at Temple Emanu-El
On October 12, 1912, 'Abdu'l-Bahá addressed an audience of approximately 2,000 at Temple Emanu-El in San Francisco — the largest synagogue on the Pacific coast — and asked the gathered Jews, with all the courtesy of a guest and all the firmness of a prophet's son, why they had not yet honoured Christ and Muḥammad as the heirs of Moses.
The Place of Honor: Louis Gregory at the Persian Legation Luncheon
On April 23, 1912, after speaking at Howard University in the morning, 'Abdu'l-Bahá was the principal guest at a diplomatic luncheon at the home of Persian chargé d'affaires Ali-Kuli Khan. One hour before the hour, the Master sent for Louis Gregory — the African-American Bahá'í who had not been invited — and seated him in the place of honor.