BibTeX:
@incollection{Various,
  author = {Various},
  title = {But it was not the same with Thornton Chase},
  booktitle = {bahaistories.com archive},
  url = {https://bahaistories.com/subject/archives},
}

APA:
Various. But it was not the same with Thornton Chase. In *bahaistories.com archive*.

MLA:
Various. "But it was not the same with Thornton Chase." *bahaistories.com archive*, n.d..

Chicago:
Various. "But it was not the same with Thornton Chase." In *bahaistories.com archive*, n.d..